Saturday, April 3, 2021

Lar Retro-resto Shure M65 Phono Preamp


Hamingredient inspired chassis 😉

In the early 2000s, I tried to unload a half dozen or so of my used/test good Telefunken 12AX7s on eBay. The buyer promptly requested for a return claiming that they didn't test well in his TV-7. Was that a sign...? 😉 
So instead of re-listing, I stashed them away. I had forgotten about their existence until they showed up during a 2020 lockdown clean-up spree. 

Shure M65

I met my buddy Lar through Audiomart in the late '80s. He's a trained sound engineer and audio hobbyist who shares my passion for the classic Austin Mini.👍 We hang out and talk shop at ham radio festivals, audio and radio shows. He's firmly committed to tube phono circuits employing active RIAA EQ and posts his projects at Audiokarma and Lenco Heaven.

Shure M65 schematic

The classic Shure M65 "chrome cutie" (as Lar fondly calls them) is one of his favorite platforms for modification. Keen eyes will notice the similarity of this topology to the phono section of the classic Dynaco PAM-1 and PAS-2/3 tube preamps, albeit operated at a lower B+ voltage and with AC heated filaments.

One channel shown

The 0.47uf ceramic disc input coupling caps, C1 and C2 + the 1M shunt resistors, R3 and R4 are discarded. Likewise, the 100k positive feedback resistors (R11 and R12) are eliminated, which I also used to do to my Dyna PAS preamp hacks. IME, this procedure improves transparency. The most significant performance upgrade is Lar's recomputed RIAA EQ capacitor values (see the above schematic) tweaked for flatter response.

I didn't have a Shure M65 but had enough parts to clone one so I could put my rediscovered Tele 12AX7s into good use in the midst of Covid-19 lockdown.


This one chassis configuration sounded fine on first turn on but had an annoying low level hum I couldn't eradicate. 


After trying all possible grounding schemes, I yanked the power transformer out and built an outboard power supply. Problem solved!


My power supply is slightly more sophisticated than the stock M65. The full wave rectified B+ is filtered by a 20H/20mA choke followed by a 47uf/450V cap, which splits to separate left and right channel rails with additional decoupling and filtering. The tube filaments are DC heated. 

1 kHz
stock RIAA EQ

Using the stock RIAA EQ capacitor values, lower frequencies sound bloated with a noticeable treble boost as noted in the Shure M65 literature, which is also visible in the above 1 kHz square wave.

1 kHz
LAR modified RIAA EQ

The 1 kHz square wave is squarer and the phono preamp sounds so much better with Lar's tweaked cap values!

I don't think I was ever able to derive this level of musical satisfaction from any of my past 12AX7 phono efforts using active RIAA EQ. I believe the sonic purity stems from the simplicity of the circuit itself. The Dynaco PAM-1 and PAS-2/3 circuits have an additional cap after the negative feedback RIAA EQ tap + elaborate switching and a balance control in the PAS, all of which can cause veiling. 

In spite of the Shure 5000 ohm output impedance spec, this is still a relatively high output Z device. When connected directly to the 10k ohm input of my Nobsound NS-02g amp, the loss of extension at both frequency extremes was discernible. It sounded best driving a 100k ohm load using low capacitance cables, 3 ft. long, max! 


This phono preamp synergized very well with my favorite magnetic cartridges with conical stylus - Nagaoka MP10, Pickering XV15, Shure M3D and M7D, amongst others. So after a couple of months of enjoying the Lar mod M65, I decided to build it on a nicer (if a bit cramped 😁) cast aluminum box with two pairs of inputs.

Instead of boring you with audiophile adjectives, I'll just say that my RCA passive RIAA EQ octal sounds effortless and airy, while the EAR 834P derived loctal is detailed and dynamic and the Lar retro-resto Shure M65 is sweet and alluring! 


This phono preamp is a most welcome addition to my tools for enjoying LP reproduction. I highly recommend following Lar's phono preamp adventures at Audiokarma! 

Bravo Lar!👏



Friday, March 19, 2021

Snell Type JIII Part 1 - Deconstructed > Re-Foam

 In the late 80s, I could have gotten a Snell Type E or J after unloading my Magnepan SMGas. But I loved the sound of EMI and Decca recordings, for which I give credit to BBC-trained sound engineers, so I invested in a pair of Quad ESL57s and Rogers LS3/5As instead. I was such an Anglophile that I even became a partner in a company that imported Art Audio Amplifiers and Spendor Speakers to the Philippines. Unfortunately, we didn't make money...but that's another story.🤣

 
During a moment of nostalgia, I chanced upon this pair of Snell JIIIs online. I messaged the seller expressing interest. After two weeks of silence, I made a polite follow-up and was surprised to receive a reply that they were still available. According to the seller, he's had several offers from tire-kicking flippers but he chose to sell to me because I sounded like an enthusiast who'd give them a good home.😄


Typical of speakers from this era, the foam surrounds have disintegrated. Other than that, this is a very clean pair with consecutive serial numbers just like when they were sold in high-end audio salons in the late 80s to early 90s.


While waiting for the replacement foam surrounds, I thoroughly cleaned all vestiges of old foam from the cone and speaker frame. This was the most tedious and time consuming step in the re-foaming process but essential for a successful result!

 Meanwhile, I also took advantage of the down time to analyze what makes this speaker system tick. 

Deconstruction


Peter Snell was a very gifted speaker designer. Due to his untimely demise at age 38 in 1984, speaker models that were manufactured during his lifetime have developed a following. Peter Qvortrop of Audio Note UK was a big fan of the 2-way Type E, J and K models and continues their legacy in the Audio Note E, J and K using custom drivers and boutique parts.

The Snell E and J had front mounted reflex ports while the K was a sealed box/acoustic suspension design, which employed a different woofer. A rear firing 3/4" dome tweeter was added to the EII model, while the reflex port was moved to the back of the cabinet in both the EII and JII.

Vifa D26TG-05-006

The EIII, JIII and KII designation denotes the switch from a Tonegen 1" doped silk dome tweeter to the Vifa D26TG-05-006 6 ohm 1" dome pictured above. A tweeter level control was also added on all models. 

According to the Snell Type JIII brochure, the Vifa D26 tweeter handles an octave of upper midrange frequencies from 2.7kHz + another two octaves of harmonic overtones.


Even if the JIII was manufactured posthumously, it retains the cabinet dimensions and proportions of the original model. After many years of experimenting with open bafflesAltec 614 and 618 and  cabinets, I'm a firm believer in the acoustic superiority of Rubenesque front baffles over Victoria's Secret slim waifs.😆 



Was the use of plywood (top, bottom and sides) + chipboard (front baffle and back panel) chosen for acoustic reasons? Regardless, the cabinet is of pretty high quality construction with particular attention placed on rigidity - see the brace from the front baffle to the back panel in the picture below.



Good quality air core inductors, electrolytic and film capacitors or a combination of both + an L-pad for tweeter level adjustment were used in the crossover network.



The high-pass is a straightforward 12 dB/octave 2nd order slope hinged at 2.7kHz, as previously mentioned. On the other unit, there was an additional electrolytic cap in the high-pass section with a higher total capacitance reading. This confirms Snell's claim of matching their units to within +/- 0.2dB based on a reference model in their factory. 

Likewise, the low-pass section is also a 2nd order slope + an EQ/contour network for the Vifa woofer (see the LCR combo highlighted in red above). Explaining how this EQ works is beyond my technical ability. My empirical mind just knows that it "shapes" the woofer's frequency response. A similar, albeit more complex, crossover + EQ can be found in the BBC LS3/5A

Since all the capacitors measured close to their indicated values, there was no rationale to change or upgrade. Besides, I want to hear these speakers as close to how they were originally designed.


Vifa 8" M21WN-07-04

AFAIK, the Vifa 8" M21WN-07-04 was the only woofer used in the J, JII and JIII. Based on the 49Hz-20kHz +/- frequency response specified in the JIII brochure, and cross-referenced to my Musical Instrument Frequency Chart, this drive unit/cabinet combo was tasked to cover six and a half octaves of musical information starting from the bass frequencies up to midrange fundamentals. 


Re-Foam


After judiciously sifting through audio sites on the net, I chose the $25/pr. foam surrounds from Simply Speakers because they were recommended by audio hobbyists who exhibited good ears and common sense. Check their re-foaming video for a straightforward and confidence-inspiring tutorial.



 The Vifa M21 voice coil is essentially self-centering. So don't even consider cutting or removing the dust-cap to shim the voice coil. It'll be ruined because the cone + dust cap is one whole piece. 

 

Not bad for a first attempt in replacing foam surrounds, huh? 😉


Since time immemorial, I've been evaluating drivers bare naked (or mounted in a simple baffle) to hear their potential. After 25 years of enjoying Altecs, these drivers sound very different...🤔  


Snell JIII in room RTA (Onyx iPhone app
Snell JIII specs

I have to live with this speaker system for a while and play lots of tunes 🎻♫🎶♬🎺and will report back in Part 2!😊


See Part 2 and Part 3

Friday, March 5, 2021

Parallel Single Ended 6SN7 [Headphone] Amp


Ever since I grafted a 6SN7 on the line stage section of my hacked Dyna PAS preamp, I've been hooked on the "octal sound." Could it be the higher heater current draw boiling more electrons and/or larger stature that give it a 3-D quality, richer tonal color, detail, dynamics + more, compared to their 9-pin/noval siblings? 


For these reasons, I've longed to hear how the ubiquitous 6SN7 could sound as a milliwatt amp. The Covid-19 2020 lockdown was a good opportunity to try "off the cuff" experiments. An unbuilt Chinese 6V6 preamp kit I bought at an Amazon closeout languishing in the basement for a couple of years provided a nice pre-punched chassis + power transformer for this project.

Ideally, the 3850 ohm plate resistance of the two triode sections of a 6SN7 connected in parallel should drive a 12K primary Z. I considered getting a pair of Hammond 125BSE output transformers, which have the flexibility of reflecting back a 2.5K, 5K or 10K primary Z but I already had a pair of these 5.5K:4 ohm SE OPTs in my parts bin that I was sure would fit under the chassis.  

!!!WARNING!!! 

The voltages in this project are potentially lethal! Proceed at your own risk!

The circuit is a simple 2-stage cascade - 1 triode section of a 6CG7 functions as the input/driver stage R-C coupled to paralleled 6SN7 triode sections.  


The HT supply output of the 6X5 rectifier feeds a 22uf/450V capacitor, which splits into left and right channel B+ rails via two 5H/50mA chokes filtered by separate 47uf/450V caps, provide clean power to the amp. I rectified the filament supply to run at 6VDC for minimum hum and noise on headphones. 

Square waves at 100Hz, 1 kHz and 10 kHz
Top trace = audio generator
Bottom trace = amplifier output

Due to the primary impedance mismatch previously noted and the bonsai stature of the transformer itself,  these square waves show limited extension at both frequency extremes. Subjectively, this was more apparent via speakers rather than on headphones. I should point out that the absolute lack of ringing is indicative of a competently-wound transformer.


Input sensitivity = 0.9 V RMS 
Output = 2.408 V RMS/ 8 ohm load = 720 milliwatts/channel
Between 16 ohms > 600 ohms, I measured 3.5 --> 4.2V RMS output, which was more than enough power for the most inefficient ortho-dynamic headphones I have in my collection.  


This amp draws the listener to focus on the midrange in which most musical activity transpires. It made the JLH HP amp sound comparatively veiled in the midrange, which shifted the listener's attention to the frequency extremes where the JLH actually does pretty well.


Despite the superior bandwidth of the output transformers fitted to the Darling amp, JEL style, the PSE6SN7 amp displaced it musically! The Darling amp just couldn't keep up with the DHT-like harmoniousness and graceful overload characteristics of the PSE6SN7. 
 

Lush and caramel flavored midrange, nuanced dynamics, silky highs and well-defined bass (within limits) are the virtues of this Lilliputian amp. Perhaps due to the high output impedance and low damping factor, this amp can portray the sophisticated qualities I've experienced from the SE171A10/VT25 and Western Electric 205D amplifiers!


Monday, February 22, 2021

Happy Birthday Daddy!


Daddy was born 94 years ago.



Family Picture, ca. '91


Dad on his 89th birthday with Mom and grandkids!



Daddy and Mommy were soulmates for 58 blissful years in this world. Now they're reunited! 

We love you and miss you both dearly!



Monday, February 8, 2021

Happy Birthday Mommy!

Picture of me and my Mom taken by my Dad


My beloved Mom would've turned 87 today.

She was a very loving, dedicated and supportive wife, mom, and grandmother!


Mommy with her youngest grandchild


Mommy completed a Bachelor of Science Degree in Education, major in Math.  


She also loved music and played the piano.


While teaching high school mathematics, Mom took music courses that would lead towards an Associate's Degree in Music Education. Meanwhile, Dad had just returned to Manila from post-graduate studies at The Juilliard School and got appointed as a faculty member at the same music school where my mom enrolled.

That was the beginning of their beautiful and idyllic love story! 


That's me, the first of four brats!


Our Family, early 80s


Dad and Mom's 25th Anniversary
December 1983


90s Family Pic


Mom and Dad's 50th
wedding anniversary, 2008


Mom and Dad, Feb. 8, 2014
Mom's 80th birthday



Dad and Mom's 56th
wedding anniversary, 2014


Mom
May 2015


Mom and Dad's 58th
wedding anniversary, 2016


Christmas 2016 was the last time the family was together.
Tish and I flew back to the USA on January 23, 2017.


Sadly, Daddy left us on May 23, 2017. 


Mommy joined Daddy on January 23, 2021.


We sorely miss you, Daddy and Mommy, but we're very happy you're together again!